New York City is home to some of the best Italian restaurants outside of Italy. Whether you’re craving a traditional plate of pasta, wood-fired pizza, or contemporary Italian dishes, NYC has something to satisfy every taste. In this guide, we’ve rounded up the top 10 best Italian restaurants in New York City that are known for their authentic flavors, ambiance, and exceptional service.
Ready to experience the best of Italian cuisine in the heart of NYC? Keep reading to discover these must-visit eateries!
Table of Contents
- 1. Carbone – Classic Italian in the Heart of NYC
- 2. Lupa Osteria Romana – A Roman Feast
- 3. Il Buco – A Cozy, Rustic Haven
- 4. The Modern – Contemporary Italian Dining
- 5. Emilia – A Hidden Gem for Authentic Flavors
- 6. L’Artusi – Modern Italian with a Twist
- 7. Del Posto – Fine Dining in the Meatpacking District
- 8. Ai Caccia – A Journey Through Northern Italy
- 9. Babbo – Famous for Its Bold Italian Flavors
- 10. Lombardi’s – New York’s First Pizzeria
1. Carbone – Classic Italian in the Heart of NYC 🍝
Rating: 4.6/5
Carbone is an iconic Italian-American restaurant located in the heart of Greenwich Village. The restaurant offers a nostalgic take on Italian-American classics with a modern twist. From their signature veal parmesan to the mouth-watering spaghetti and meatballs, Carbone is all about indulgence and classic flavors.
Best Dishes:
- 🍝 Spaghetti and Meatballs
- 🍤 Shrimp Scampi
- 🥩 Veal Parmesan
- 🍰 Tiramisu
Reviews:
Guests rave about the restaurant’s exceptional service and classic Italian dishes with a contemporary twist.
💬 “Carbone is a must-try for anyone who loves Italian-American cuisine. The veal parm is out of this world!”
2. Lupa Osteria Romana – A Roman Feast 🍕
Rating: 4.5/5
Lupa Osteria Romana is a cozy, family-friendly restaurant offering Roman-style dishes that transport diners to the streets of Rome. From their signature cacio e pepe to a wide selection of antipasti, Lupa focuses on simple yet flavorful Italian dishes. The rustic atmosphere adds to the charm, making it a favorite spot for locals and visitors alike.
Best Dishes:
- 🍝 Cacio e Pepe
- 🍞 Focaccia with Rosemary
- 🍷 Roman-Style Carbonara
- 🍨 Tartufo Gelato
Reviews:
Patrons love Lupa for its authentic Roman flavors and intimate setting.
💬 “The cacio e pepe here is incredible—just like I had in Rome! A cozy spot with amazing food.”
3. Il Buco – A Cozy, Rustic Haven 🍷
Rating: 4.8/5
Il Buco offers a rustic, warm atmosphere that’s perfect for enjoying seasonal, locally-sourced Italian dishes. The intimate setting, coupled with an outstanding wine list, creates a dining experience that’s both sophisticated and inviting. Il Buco’s menu is focused on southern Italian flavors, with an emphasis on seafood and fresh ingredients.
Best Dishes:
- 🍤 Grilled Octopus
- 🍝 Pappardelle with Wild Boar Ragu
- 🥩 Veal Chop with Porcini Mushrooms
- 🍰 Ricotta Cheesecake
Reviews:
Guests are impressed with the refined yet cozy atmosphere and top-notch ingredients.
💬 “Il Buco serves the best Southern Italian dishes. The grilled octopus was perfectly cooked!”
4. The Modern – Contemporary Italian Dining 🍽️
Rating: 4.7/5
The Modern, located within the Museum of Modern Art (MoMA), offers a sophisticated and artful approach to Italian cuisine. With stunning views of the Abby Aldrich Rockefeller Sculpture Garden, the ambiance is as impressive as the food. The restaurant offers an inventive menu featuring contemporary Italian flavors, perfect for foodies looking for something new and creative.
Best Dishes:
- 🍝 Ricotta Gnudi
- 🍷 Roasted Lamb with Truffle
- 🍤 Lobster Salad with Citrus
- 🍮 Olive Oil Cake
Reviews:
Visitors love the blend of creativity and elegance that The Modern offers in both its food and setting.
💬 “The perfect spot for a special occasion. The lobster salad and ricotta gnudi are to die for!”
5. Emilia – A Hidden Gem for Authentic Flavors 🍴
Rating: 4.6/5
Emilia offers an intimate and cozy dining experience with a focus on rustic, northern Italian dishes. Located in the Flatiron District, the restaurant specializes in house-made pastas and locally sourced ingredients. Emilia’s menu offers dishes that are both comforting and refined, perfect for those looking for an authentic Italian experience in NYC.
Best Dishes:
- 🍝 Pappardelle with Duck Ragu
- 🍤 Roasted Shrimp with Garlic and Lemon
- 🍷 Roast Lamb with Rosemary
- 🍨 Tiramisu
Reviews:
Food enthusiasts praise the quality of the house-made pasta and fresh, bold flavors at Emilia.
💬 “Emilia’s pasta is incredible! Every bite was full of rich, authentic flavors.”
6. L’Artusi – Modern Italian with a Twist 🍝
Rating: 4.8/5
L’Artusi is a trendy spot in the West Village offering a modern take on traditional Italian cuisine. With its sleek design and open kitchen, L’Artusi provides an exciting dining experience that showcases the best of Italian cooking with a modern twist. Known for its fresh pastas and unique flavor combinations, L’Artusi is a favorite among New Yorkers and tourists alike.
Best Dishes:
- 🍝 Olive Oil Cake with Grapefruit
- 🍤 Ricotta Gnocchi
- 🍷 Roasted Chicken with Fennel
- 🍰 Tiramisu
Reviews:
L’Artusi is loved for its modern ambiance and bold take on traditional Italian dishes.
💬 “L’Artusi never disappoints! The ricotta gnocchi is amazing, and the olive oil cake is a must-try!”
7. Del Posto – Fine Dining in the Meatpacking District 🍷
Rating: 4.7/5
Del Posto is a high-end Italian restaurant located in the trendy Meatpacking District. Offering a luxurious dining experience with an extensive wine list, Del Posto serves traditional Italian dishes with exceptional quality and finesse. The spacious dining room, intimate booths, and impressive service make it perfect for special occasions or elegant nights out.
Best Dishes:
- 🍝 Fettuccine with Truffle
- 🥩 Grilled Bistecca alla Fiorentina
- 🍰 Cannoli with Ricotta
Reviews:
Guests appreciate the elegant ambiance and refined Italian flavors.
💬 “The best fine dining experience in NYC. Del Posto’s truffle fettuccine is unforgettable!”
8. Ai Caccia – A Journey Through Northern Italy 🍝
Rating: 4.5/5
Ai Caccia offers a menu inspired by the traditional flavors of Northern Italy, featuring dishes such as risottos, hearty meat dishes, and delicious pasta options. The cozy setting and focus on fresh, locally-sourced ingredients make Ai Caccia a favorite for those looking to experience authentic northern Italian flavors.
Best Dishes:
- 🍝 Risotto with Wild Mushrooms
- 🍷 Braised Short Ribs
- 🍰 Panna Cotta with Berries
Reviews:
Guests love the cozy ambiance and the northern Italian flavors that come together perfectly.
💬 “Ai Caccia’s risotto is the best I’ve had in the city. The braised short ribs are also a standout!”
9. Babbo – Famous for Its Bold Italian Flavors 🍷
Rating: 4.8/5
Babbo, located in Greenwich Village, is an upscale Italian restaurant helmed by celebrity chef Mario Batali. Known for its bold flavors and innovative dishes, Babbo offers an unforgettable Italian dining experience. The menu features a mix of rustic and contemporary Italian fare with dishes that reflect Batali’s love for fresh ingredients and bold, inventive flavors.
Best Dishes:
- 🍝 Pappardelle with Oxtail Ragu
- 🍤 Roasted Lobster with Chive Butter
- 🍰 Chocolate Cake with Hazelnut
Reviews:
Babbo is loved for its creative approach to Italian cuisine, offering bold flavors and exceptional service.
💬 “Babbo never disappoints. The oxtail ragu is incredible, and the chocolate cake is divine!”
10. Lombardi’s – New York’s First Pizzeria 🍕
Rating: 4.5/5
As the first pizzeria in New York City, Lombardi’s holds a special place in the city’s culinary history. Known for its delicious coal-fired pizza, Lombardi’s serves up classic Italian pizzas with fresh ingredients and a crispy, chewy crust. Located in Little Italy, this iconic pizzeria offers an authentic taste of New York’s pizza legacy.
Best Dishes:
- 🍕 Margherita Pizza
- 🍕 Pepperoni Pizza
- 🍷 Garlic Bread with Mozzarella
Reviews:
Visitors flock to Lombardi’s for a taste of history and its mouthwatering coal-fired pizzas.
💬 “Lombardi’s pizza is a New York classic! The Margherita pizza has the perfect balance of flavors.”
Conclusion
New York City offers an incredible array of Italian dining experiences that range from traditional to contemporary. Whether you’re looking for a cozy trattoria or a sophisticated, fine-dining experience, these ten Italian restaurants are guaranteed to deliver exceptional food, memorable moments, and a true taste of Italy. So, grab a fork, indulge in some pasta, and enjoy the flavors of one of the world’s most beloved cuisines!
FAQs
What is the best Italian restaurant for families in NYC?
Lupa Osteria Romana is an excellent option for families. It offers a cozy, welcoming atmosphere and classic Roman dishes that appeal to all ages.
Where can I find authentic Italian pizza in NYC?
Lombardi’s Pizzeria is New York’s first pizzeria and a fantastic place to experience authentic coal-fired pizza in the heart of Little Italy.
Are reservations required at these Italian restaurants?
Yes, especially for popular spots like Carbone, L’Artusi, and Del Posto. It’s always a good idea to make a reservation in advance to avoid long wait times.
